Old Mission Investment Company, LLC logo

Old Mission Investment Company, LLC

Updated today

Client assets under management

$862,710,181

Clients

1,051

6% high-net worth

Advisors

8

of 10 employees

Firm type

Team

4-10 advisors or $500M+ in AUM

Clients per advisor

131

Very High

Average account size

$820,847

About

Old Mission Investment Company provides fee-based investment management and financial planning to individuals, high‑net‑worth clients, trusts, retirement plans, pension plans, and certain business entities. Services include discretionary portfolio management using mutual funds, exchange‑traded funds, individual stocks and bonds, along with estate and broader financial planning coordination.

The firm generally manages accounts on a discretionary basis and employs fundamental analysis and asset‑allocation driven model portfolios (six model allocations) tailored to each client’s risk profile and time horizon. Old Mission favors a low‑turnover, long‑term approach, conducts ongoing portfolio reviews, and delivers quarterly portfolio reports while typically custodying assets at Fidelity for execution and custody services.

Noteworthy distinctions include an affiliation with Old Mission Trust Company, a privately held South Dakota trust company owned by the firm’s members, with shared employees and administrative arrangements and a stated policy to terminate the advisory relationship if the trust assumes trustee duties. The brochure also discloses principals who hold insurance licenses and solicitor relationships with local banks (including a disclosed referral fee and short‑term sub‑lease arrangement with Honor State Bank), and notes receipt of complimentary business and compliance newsletters and other non‑cash services from its primary custodian — all disclosed as potential conflicts of interest.

Client services

Financial planning Portfolio management Selection of other advisers Newsletters or periodicals Consultation services

Expertise

Wealth management General estate planning guidance

Fee options

Fixed

Project fees ranging from $500 to $10,000

Percentage

0.25% to 1.75% annually (negotiable)

Project-based

$150 to $275 per hour depending on complexity and scope

Main office location

Old Mission Investment Company, LLC

880 Munson Avenue, Suite B

Traverse City MI 49686, United States

Number of offices

3

Most active in

California · Colorado · Florida · Illinois · Indiana · Louisiana · Michigan · Nebraska · North Carolina · Oregon · Texas

Disclosures

Exclamation point means they have disclosures of this type. Check mark means no disclosures of this type were found.

Business activities & affiliations

Advisors at this firm

user avatar

Keith O

Series 63, Series 65

Traverse City, MI

Old Mission Investment Company, LLC

Keith Olshove is a financial advisor at Old Mission Investment Company, LLC in Traverse City, MI, with 11 years of industry experience. He holds Series 63 and Series 65 licenses and has been with Old Mission since 2014. Olshove serves on the investment committee of Old Mission Trust Company, contributing to trust administration, investment management, and tax management services. Old Mission Investment Company provides fee-based investment management, financial planning, and estate planning to individuals, trusts, retirement and pension plans, charitable organizations, and business entities. The firm emphasizes customized, low-turnover portfolios based on client risk profiles and fundamental analysis, managing accounts primarily on a discretionary basis.

Wealth management General estate planning guidance
user avatar

Carey T

CFP®, Series 65

Traverse City, MI

Old Mission Investment Company, LLC

Carey Tafelsky is a CFP® professional with 11 years of industry experience, currently serving at Old Mission Investment Company, LLC since 2014. She holds a Series 65 license and participates on the investment committee of Old Mission Trust Company, where she is involved in trust administration, investment management, and tax management services. Old Mission Investment Company provides fee-based investment management, financial planning, and estate planning to individuals, trusts, retirement plans, and other entities. The firm emphasizes customized portfolios based on client risk profiles, using fundamental analysis and asset allocation to implement low-turnover, long-term strategies.

Wealth management General estate planning guidance
user avatar

Susan W

CFP®, Series 65

Traverse City, MI

Old Mission Investment Company, LLC

Susan Wipperman is a CFP® with eight years of industry experience, currently serving as a financial advisor at Old Mission Investment Company, LLC since 2017. She previously worked at Fifth Third Bank for 12 years. Outside of her advisory role, she serves on the board of directors for B May Bags, a women's handbag manufacturer, and is a member of the investment committee at Old Mission Trust Company. Old Mission Investment Company provides fee-based investment management, financial planning, and estate planning services to individuals, trusts, retirement plans, and organizations. The firm employs customized, risk-profile-driven portfolios with a focus on low-turnover, long-term strategies and manages accounts primarily on a discretionary basis.

Wealth management General estate planning guidance
user avatar

Jeffrey J

Series 63, Series 65

Traverse City, MI

Old Mission Investment Company, LLC

Jeffrey Johnson is a financial advisor with Old Mission Investment Company, LLC in Traverse City, MI, holding Series 63 and Series 65 licenses and bringing 27 years of industry experience. He has worked with Purshe Kaplan Sterling Investments and Old Mission Investments since 2006. He serves on the board of directors for Old Mission Trust Company, a related trust services firm. Old Mission Investment Company provides fee-based investment management, financial planning, and estate planning services to individuals, trusts, retirement plans, and charitable organizations. The firm uses customized portfolios based on client risk profiles, employing fundamental analysis and asset allocation to implement low-turnover, long-term strategies.

Wealth management General estate planning guidance
user avatar

Ryan K

Series 65

Traverse City, MI

Old Mission Investment Company, LLC

Ryan Knabusch is a financial advisor at Old Mission Investment Company, LLC with eight years of industry experience. He holds a Series 65 designation and previously worked at Sandbox Financial Partners LLC, Sculati Wealth Management, LLC, and Plante Moran Financial Advisors. Old Mission Investment Company provides fee-based investment management, financial planning, and estate planning to individuals, trusts, retirement plans, pension plans, charitable organizations, and business entities. The firm emphasizes customized, low-turnover portfolios based on client risk profiles, using fundamental analysis and asset allocation, and manages accounts primarily on a discretionary basis.

Wealth management General estate planning guidance
user avatar

Kurt S

Series 63, Series 65

Traverse City, MI

Old Mission Investment Company, LLC

Kurt Schuler is a financial advisor with Old Mission Investment Company, LLC in Traverse City, MI, holding Series 63 and Series 65 licenses and bringing 33 years of industry experience. He has worked with Old Mission Investments since 2006 and previously with Purshe Kaplan Sterling Investments. Schuler also serves as Chief Information Officer for Old Mission Trust Company, where he organizes and maintains client data systems. Old Mission Investment Company provides fee-based investment management, financial planning, and estate planning services to individuals, trusts, retirement plans, pension plans, charitable organizations, and business entities. The firm uses customized portfolios based on client risk profiles and employs fundamental analysis, asset allocation, and model portfolios to implement low-turnover, long-term strategies.

Wealth management General estate planning guidance
user avatar

Lindsay F

CFP®, Series 66

Traverse City, MI

Old Mission Investment Company, LLC

Lindsay Fitzpatrick is a CFP® and Series 66 licensed advisor with 12 years of industry experience. She has worked at Old Mission Investment Company, LLC since 2019 and previously held positions at Rehmann Financial Network, LLC and Royal Alliance. Fitzpatrick serves on the Finance Committee Board of the YWCA Great Lakes Bay Region, where she reviews financial statements and investment management. Old Mission Investment Company provides fee-based investment management, financial planning, and estate planning services to individuals, trusts, retirement plans, and charitable organizations. The firm focuses on customized portfolios based on client risk profiles, utilizing fundamental analysis and asset allocation to implement long-term, low-turnover strategies.

Wealth management General estate planning guidance
user avatar

Christopher L

Series 63, Series 65

Traverse City, MI

Old Mission Investment Company, LLC

Christopher Lamb is a financial advisor with Old Mission Investment Company, LLC in Traverse City, MI, holding Series 63 and Series 65 licenses and having 32 years of industry experience. He has worked at Old Mission Investments since 2006 and previously spent 12 years at Purshe Kaplan Sterling Investments. Lamb also serves as president and CEO of Old Mission Trust Company, which provides corporate trustee services. Old Mission Investment Company offers fee-based investment management, financial and estate planning to individuals, trusts, retirement plans, pension plans, charitable organizations, and business entities. The firm uses customized, low-turnover, long-term strategies based on fundamental analysis and asset allocation, managing portfolios on both discretionary and non-discretionary bases.

Wealth management General estate planning guidance
Warmer team member

Not sure where to start?

We'll help you think it through – whether you ultimately need an advisor or not.

Call (201) 292-4557

Warmer provides personalized recommendations and introductions to independent fiduciary advisors. We do not supervise advisors, manage or hold assets, guarantee performance, or provide advice about specific investments.

Each advisor listed on our site is an independent fiduciary responsible for their own advice. Warmer may receive fees from advisors for participation or referrals; these fees are paid by advisors and do not affect the fees clients pay for advisory services.

For advisor listings, we rely on sources including public filings and data provided by advisors, and we cannot guarantee that all information is current or accurate. Please review an advisor's Form ADV and do your own diligence before entering into an advisory relationship.

By using our service, you agree to Warmer's Terms of Service and Advisory Agreement and Privacy Policy. Logos provided by Logo.dev

© 2026 Warmer Holdings Inc. ("Warmer")